| Title | Research Products Accounting: Architecture and Interoperability Guidelines |
|---|---|
| URI | https://zenodo.org/record/8362353(this is the newest version) |
| Revised version links | |
| Link to Metadata | |
| Date Issued to EIAC | 02.05.2023 |
| Submitted by | Dimitris Pierrakos (OpenAIRE AMKE) and Paolo Manghi (OpenAIRE AMKE) |
| Outcome of EIAC review | endorsed, 22.08.23 |
| Date Issued to EIAB | 22.08.23 |
| Outcome of EIAB review | endorsed, 29.08.23 https://docs.google.com/document/d/1igE7knhOkvVF0GJituO-DRz-ms3jUlWCAMBZKjhtcjw/edit. (this version was endorsed) |
| On portal? | yes, published 29.09.23 |
Overview
The proposed document has been submitted for inclusion in the EOSC Interoperability Framework.
Comments should be made either on eiac@eoscfuture.eu, where they will be archived for future reference or added to the change log below. Comments posted to other discussion methods will not be included in the review.
Statements of Support/Deny
All members of the EIAC are encouraged to make a statement of support or dissension in consideration of this proposal.
Name | Organisation | Support or Deny | Reason (if denied) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jorik van Kemenade | SURF | support | |
| Paul Gondim van Dongen | SURF | support | |
| Sabeel Shah | support | ||
Comment/Change Log
Please fill in any comments or proposed changes below or add them as issues on the github repository.
Number | Current Text | Proposed Text / Query | Commenter | Action |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Section 3: The service forms metrics of usage activity of EOSC Data sources, categorizing the data retrieved by number of downloads, number of views, number of repositories and all derivative quantitative open metrics | Could this be integrated in section 2? | Paul Gondim van Dongen (SURF) | OK |
| 2 | Section 4: High-level Service Architecture | It can be clearer if the components are described before the workflow. | Paul Gondim van Dongen (SURF) | OK |
| 3 | Section 10: Interoperability Guidelines | I noticed that in other guidelines this section has a paragraph describing its purpose. Could be better for clarity if there was one here too. | Paul Gondim van Dongen (SURF) | OK |
| 4 | Section 10.1.1: A set of parameters are required for the configuration of the software above, which are summarised in the Table below: | Are there parameter sets documented elsewhere too? If so, would links to the original location be easier to maintain? | Paul Gondim van Dongen (SURF) | OK |
| 5 | Section 1: Intended Audience | Could this section be a little bit more textual, so that these groups have an idea of what to expect from reading the document? | Paul Gondim van Dongen (SURF) | OK |
| 6 | Section 2: Description and main features | Is EOSC Research Products Accounting service == OpenAIRE UsageCounts service ? this is not clear | Andrea Manzi(EGI Foundation) | OK |
| 7 | Section 4: High-level Service Architecture | Workflow description moved before the figure | Andrea Manzi(EGI Foundation) | OK |
| 8 | Section 9: Integration Procedure | It's not clear which steps are belonging to the push workflow and which ones to the pull workflow | Andrea Manzi(EGI Foundation) | OK |
| 9 | Section 10.1.2: PULL Workflow | better to refer explicitly to Table 2 | Andrea Manzi(EGI Foundation) | OK |
| 10 | Section 11: Examples of solutions implementing this specification | It would be better to add also a small paragraph for the 2 services implementing the specification instead of only including the figures | Andrea Manzi(EGI Foundation) | OK |
| 11 | Intended Audience | Add: “This interoperability guideline is intended for adoption by” | Andreas Czerniak | OK |
| 12 | Description and main features | Maybe a small elaboration on what is considered an (EOSC) Data source would make things clearer. Just a suggestion. | Thanassis Mantes | OK |
| 13 | Licensing InformationCC ATTRIBUTION 4.0 INTERNATIONAL LICENSE | Link/reference to it would be nice | Thanassis Mantes | OK |
| 14 | Integration Procedure | Steps are listed in order, so I suggest it would be better to be numbered | Thanassis Mantes | OK |
| 15 | Related Guidelines | add links | Thanassis Mantes | OK |