| Title | EOSC Service Catalogue Interoperability Guidelines |
|---|---|
| URI | https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.8333871 |
| Revised version links | |
| Link to Metadata | https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1vvKYdxcHD-sU63XP8Payytyn2rVkN8KbCRfi7MI9Z-I/edit?usp=sharing |
| Date Issued to EIAC | 18.04.2023 |
| Submitted by | Thanassis Mantes, ATHENA RC |
| Outcome of EIAC review | endorsed online. 07.09.2023 |
| Date Issued to EIAB | 22.09.23 |
| Outcome of EIAB review | 27.09.23 |
| On portal? | yes |
Overview
The proposed document has been submitted for inclusion in the EOSC Interoperability Framework.
Comments should be made either on eiac@eoscfuture.eu, where they will be archived for future reference or added to the change log below. Comments posted to other discussion methods will not be included in the review.
Statements of Support/Deny
All members of the EIAC are encouraged to make a statement of support or dissension in consideration of this proposal.
Name | Organisation | Support or Deny | Reason (if denied) |
|---|---|---|---|
Gavin Farrell | ELIXIR/EMBL-EBI | Support | |
John Shepherdson | CESSDA ERIC | Support | |
Andrea Manzi | EGI Foundation | Support | |
Andreas Czerniak | Bielefeld University Library/OpenAIRE | Support | |
| Bielefeld University | Support |
Comment/Change Log
Please fill in any comments or proposed changes below.
Number | Current Text | Proposed Text / Query | Commenter | Action |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Various | Typos, as marked | John Shepherdson | Addressed |
| 2 | Abstract | missing | Addressed | |
| 3 | Table of contents | refine the numbering | Addressed | |
| 4 | clarification of terms | use of resource, services or mixed up | Addressed | |
| 5 | linking like "Resource/Provider Profiles (v 3.0, v 4.0)" and some "dead links" | should be double-check | Andreas Czerniak | Addressed |
| 6 | double-check on references and table numbers | Andreas Czerniak | Addressed | |
| 7 | Acronyms table | In suggested mode for minor changes | Gavin Farrell | Addressed |
| 8 | Section 3. Intended Audience | Minor suggested revisions for readability, accessibility of acronyms | Addressed | |
| 9 | Section 4. Description and main features | Sugested reference links and abbreviations harmonisation to table/first use Minor text suggested edits Description and main features overall note: section should be geared as the most easy to understand section, use as many refs to outsider terms or even cross ref to further explanations if further down the doc. Should be inviting to EOSC outsider to understand and consider the audience carefully to ensure they make it past this first point equipped with all the knowledge they need or ability to find this knowoledge on all insider terms e.g. of terms in use: Research Infrastructure/Cluster/EOSC Future(Core) Components/EOSC Resource Catalogue/EOSC Research Product Catalogue/EOSC Service Catalogue/EOSC Providers Portal/EOSC Service Registry/+... All very heavy bulky concepts for the average service provider/researcher - perhaps consider a pre explainer section on these main concepts in a few sentences or outlinks to where info can be found before this section? | Partially Addressed | |
| 10 | Section 5. Response to Community Need | Very minor bullet format edits - full stops/commas | Addressed | |
| 11 | Section 6. High-level Service Architecture | Very minor suggested edits Settle on use of M or Mi - then for B vs Bi for highlighting numeric units of scle | Addressed | |
| 11 | Section 9/ Related Guidelines | OpenAIRE Explore is not an EOSC IF IG - Suggested subbing in one of Alessia/Paolos upcoming Guideliens instead if they make mention of this/ otherwise just change section to 'Related Guideines and Services ' | Addressed | |
| 12 | All on doc | Refernece to the EOSC Core and Components then to settle on use of terminology for this: EOSC Future components is in use but it is the EOSC Future Core components that are being mentioned and referenced. Prefeence would be to harmonise the temrinology to mentino Core especially when we have Core EOSC IF IGs | Gavin Farrell | Addressed |
| 13 | Sections 10-13 | Very minor edits - very good and clear | Addressed | |
| 14 | Section 14. References | More references needed throughout as suggested in doc - first half of doc lacks in average non-EOSC person accessibility for the volume of internal terms and lack of refs to what they are. | Partially Addressed, same as comment 9 | |
| 15 | Various | Post update typos, as marked | John Shepherdson | Addressed |